Is there anything more chic than scarlet lipstick and smoldering eyeshadow? Thanks to its Old Hollywood roots and high-impact glamour, this timeless pairing is a makeup mainstay no matter the season. But even the classics need a re-invention every now and then. Check out Emma Watson and Taylor Swift, who each put their own twist on this ravishing combo.

Emma proves that you don’t need a deep tan to pull off the bronze bombshell look—warm eyeshadow and dewy skin will do the trick! Her slick, side-parted chignon and full brows creates a young, modern edge, but that bold pout is totally sophisticated. Since this particular hue of rouge has blue undertones, it ties into her super cool look.

Silvery smoky eyes, blunt bangs, and a set of mega-long lashes are a surefire recipe for peepers that pop. To take her look to the next level, Taylor adds bright, matte lipstick into the mix. Her shade of choice is a beautiful blend of red and orange, creating a rich, summer-ready statement lip. Loose waves add a fresh, casual twist to her big-night-out maquillage.

Although they’ve mastered the classics, these stars are anything but old-school. So, whose twist on this tried-and-true look should win this beauty battle? Vote here, and make sure you tell us who won you over in the comments section below!